In awful weather conditions, both teams tried to find their rhythm. The Green-Whites slowly gained the upper hand in the game, and began to exert more pressure on their hosts. They could not find the telling touch however, coming closest through shots from Clemens Fritz and Aron Johansson. The American’s effort in particular would have been a stunning individual goal, had the home side’s goalkeeper not saved well with his legs.
Werder then suffered a setback against the run of play in the 39th minute, as Maurice Litka made the most of St. Pauli’s first shot on goal to give the second-tier team a 1-0 lead at half time in Hamburg. Amongst a host of changes at the break and throughout the second period, Clemens Fritz made way, and Garcia, one of only four Green-Whites to play the full 90 minutes, was handed the captain’s armband.